Contrary to what many sources
claim, the P-38 Lightning did not shoot down more Japanese aircraft
in World War Two than any
other American or Allied aircraft. The numbers do not support that
statement. (In red below)
Even
when combining the number of victories in PTO - Pacific Theatre of
Operations and CBI - China-Burma-India, the P-38, with
a total of 1,857 victories, came in
third place behind the F6F Hellcat with 5,160 and the F4U Corsair with
2,140.
Since the F6F and the F4U were both USN/USMC aircraft, it would be accurate
to state that the P-38 shot down more Japanese aircraft
only if the statement is qualified for United States Army Air Forces (USAAF)
aircraft ONLY.
Speaking strictly about USAAF victories,
the P-38 Lightening wins with 1,857, with the P-40 running a close second at 1,633.5.
The best I
can tell, one author many years ago stated that the P-38 shot down more
Japanese aircraft than any other USAAF aircraft. Later, another
author took this information but just stated that P-38 shot down more
Japanese aircraft than any other aircraft. The important qualifier
of USAAF was deleted. Then it has become the classic case of other
author's using the second author's information without doing the
necessary historical research. Therefore, this incorrect
information has been incorrectly re-quoted in many publications since
then. I have even heard airshow announcers make this error.
Even though the F6F did not start reaching
Naval and Marine units in the Pacific until late 1943, once it did it came
in prodigious numbers. The Naval carrier forces and Marine land-based
units concentrated on the destruction of both the Japanese Naval and
Army Air Forces in that theater. In the Battle of the Marianas, on
June 11, 1944, Hellcats shot down 70 Japanese aircraft. Six days later on June
19th, they shot down another 354 enemy planes in "The Great
Marianas Turkey Shoot". In two days, the F6F destroyed 23% of
what it took the P-38 the entire conflict in the Pacific to do. The F6F Hellcat has been
somewhat forgotten and overlooked, considering it was the top US fighter in
the Pacific and second only to the P-51 Mustang for total victories in
the war. The F4U Corsair, another Marine and Navy fighter and the
second place finisher in the destruction of Japanese warplanes in air to
air combat, was used more by the US Marines than the Navy. For the most
part. the F4U Corsair operated from land bases in the Pacific and did not have the
opportunities that the F6F had.
Two other
aircraft that have been overlooked are the P-47's and P-51B/C's importance to the
invasion of Western Europe at Normandy on June 6, 1944. In order
for the landings to be successful, air supremacy over the Luftwaffe had
to be obtained. It was the early P-51B/Cs and P-47s that accomplished this task.
Although the later P-51D Mustang may have
captured the honors, it did not arrive in significant quantities
until the time of the Normandy invasion. These two aircraft have
been over looked for their contribution to the successful
Allied invasion on D-Day.
Also note the
138 victories by the Douglas SBD Dauntless. The 1942 book
"Queen of the Flattops" by Stanley Johnston, which is the story of the
original USS Lexington on her final cruise into the South Pacific and her
eventual loss at the Battle of the Coral Sea, documents that the SBDs on that cruise
were very active in engaging enemy aircraft of all types in air-to-air
combat during combat and scouting missions. One such air battle was
with the Japanese Zero.
In the final air battle defending the ship, SBDs were launched along with
the F4F Wildcats to defend the ship as the low altitude air defense
screen. At the end of the battle, Ensign John Leppla, an SBD Scout
Bomber Pilot, along with his gunner, were credited with seven kills.
This was
more than any of the fighter pilots on the USS Lexington had at the time.
|